The Best Double Electric Breast Pump for Breastfeeding and Pumping Moms
Becoming a mom for the first time comes with a steep learning curve — especially when it comes to feeding your baby. If you’re planning on breastfeeding and pumping, choosing the right breast pump can make a huge difference in your comfort, milk supply, and daily routine.
In this post, I’ll break down the best double electric breast pumps for first-time moms based on ease of use, budget, and lifestyle. Whether you plan to exclusively pump, build a freezer stash of breastmilk for going back to work, or simply want a break from nursing, there’s a pump that can work for you.
This is an insurance covered breast pump review as each of the pumps I’ve included for review are eligible for health insurance coverage. Additionally, these top three hospital-grade double electric breast pumps came directly from experienced moms (and are not sponsored), so you can be sure these are trusted options for your breastfeeding and pumping journey.
What to Look for in a Breast Pump as a First-Time Mom
Before we dive into the list, let’s cover a few key features to consider:
Comfort – Adjustable suction and quiet motors matter more than you think, but so do the size and style of the flanges. When reading pump reviews only, note that pumps may feel and work differently for different moms.
Portability – Hands-free or wearable pumps can make multitasking easier.
Ease of cleaning – Fewer parts mean less stress during those sleep-deprived days.
Insurance coverage – Many pumps are fully or partially covered, so check your personal benefits and maximize your insurance coverage for a breast pump.
Top Breast Pumps for First-Time Moms in 2025
1. Spectra S1 – Best Overall for Home Use
This hospital-grade, closed-system pump is powerful yet gentle. It has a rechargeable battery, making it slightly more portable than the S2 (which must be plugged in to work). The Spectra S1 is my personal favorite and other moms agree it’s a reliable choice for efficient and optimal output. best breast pump for low milk supply
Pros:
Hospital-Grade Performance: Delivers efficient and reliable milk expression with adjustable suction levels and cycle speeds, mimicking your baby's natural suckling rhythm.
Rechargeable Battery: Offers portability with a built-in battery, eliminating the need to be tethered to a power outlet (like the Spectra S2 and many other standard double electric breast pumps).
Nightlight Feature: Built-in nightlight facilitates nighttime pumping without disturbing others.
Cons:
Bulky Design: While lightweight, its size can make it less convenient for travel or on-the-go use.
Most Expensive: Of the top three pumps included in this post, it’s the most expensive of three and may require a small out-of-pocket cost even with insurance coverage. Make sure you check your personal benefits for health insurance coverage of a breast pump.
2. Pumpables Genie Advanced – Best Wearable Pump for Multitasking
The Pumpables Genie Advanced is a compact, portable pump that combines power with comfort, making it ideal for moms seeking flexibility without compromising performance.
Pros:
High Suction Power: Offers suction power that surpasses even the Spectra S1.
Customizable Settings: Features letdown and expression modes with various suction levels, allowing for personalized pumping sessions.
Compact and Portable: Small enough to fit into most bags, with a clip and lanyard for hands-free use.
Comfortable Flanges: Provides a range of flange sizes at checkout, ensuring a better fit and increased comfort. There are many free measuring tools online you can download and use to find the right size flanges for you.
Cons:
Cleaning Complexity: Contains multiple parts that are not dishwasher-safe and requiring handwashing, which I don’t love. Per Pumpables website duck valves, valve membranes, and backflow protector membrane, which are all made of silicone and can easily warp, should be handwashed.
Weight Consideration: Despite its small size, some users find it slightly heavy when worn around the neck with the included lanyard.
3. Elvie Stride – Best Hands-Free Pump for Flexibility
The Elvie Stride is a wearable, hands-free pump that offers the convenience of discreet pumping, making it suitable for multitasking moms.
Pros:
Hands-Free Design: Fits comfortably inside a bra, allowing for discreet and mobile pumping sessions.
App Connectivity: Controlled via the Elvie app, enabling users to adjust settings and monitor sessions remotely.
Quiet Operation: Operates quietly, making it suitable for use in various settings without drawing attention.
Customizable Settings: Offers multiple intensity levels and modes to cater to individual comfort and efficiency.
Cons:
Learning Curve: Some users report a learning curve in assembling the pump and achieving the perfect fit to prevent leaks. Family Weal
Battery Life: Heavy users might find that the battery requires frequent charging, which could be inconvenient if you’re always on the move.
Cleaning Challenges: Some users find it difficult to clean, with multiple parts requiring careful handling.
FAQs About Choosing a Breast Pump
How many breast pumps do I need?
Most moms use one main electric pump, but having a manual backup (like the Lansinoh) is helpful.
Can I get a free pump through insurance?
Yes! Many insurance providers cover one breast pump per pregnancy. Sites like Aeroflow or Pumps for Mom help you browse eligible options easily, but I always recommend contacting your insurance coverage for details on your specific benefits. Visit this blog post for more information on how to order a breast pump through your insurer.
When pumping gear do I need?
There are many pumping supplies and accessories that will be helpful to you and make your breastfeeding and pumping journey easier. I’ve gathered a list of my favorite pumping gear which has everything you’ll need. Whether you add this pumping gear to your baby registry or purchase separately is up to you, but I would recommend having these ready to go before your baby arrives.
When should I start pumping?
This depends on your feeding goals. Many first-time moms start pumping a few weeks postpartum to build a stash or get relief between feedings. I teach you how to use your pump and how to create a pumping routine, in addition to breastfeeding education and newborn care guidance in my baby prep course.
Final Thoughts: Pick the Pump That Matches Your Lifestyle
The best breast pump for you depends on your goals, routine, and comfort. This can vary from mom to mom. As a first-time mom, ease of use and comfort matter most — you’ve got enough on your plate without complicated gear. Choose what feels right for you, and give yourself grace as you learn how to use your pump and adjust to your pumping schedule.
If you’d like further help choosing a pump, use my Breast Pump Quiz to get a personalized breast pump recommendation based on your unique lifestyle and goals!
